REVIEW: The Echo by Melinda Di Lorenzo
Déjà vu can be deadly…
A year ago, Rose Mcgovern’s sister was found dead at the bottom of a bridge. A tragic accident. That’s what the police called it. What they still call it. What everyone except Rose believes to be true. But she won’t change her mind. No matter how many seconds and minutes and days go by, no matter how much time she’s had to spend in the psych ward, and no matter how much her life falls apart. She will never give up on her quest for the truth.
And now, it’s happening again.
Another woman’s body has been found. The circumstances are far too similar to be a coincidence. There might even be more victims. Which would mean that Rose was right all along. But the police have long since dismissed her as paranoid, and she’s driven away every friend she’s ever had. With nothing but her own conviction on her side, how can she prove that an accident is really a murder? And even if it’s possible, can she do it before she makes a deadly mistake and the killer claims her life, too?
Dear Ms. Di Lorenzo,
Another one of our reviewers reads a lot of mystery/thrillers and I decided to give one a try. This one attracted my attention because of the fact that Rose has had to battle not only with her own fears but the fact that so many others see her as being paranoid and won’t believe her. I wanted to know how she was going to solve this mystery and get people to take her seriously.
This was a fast read. Rose is a sympathetic character and I was on her side from the get-go. Not only has she lost her beloved sister (no mention of the parents) but despite the fact that she’s taken her concerns to the police sergeant in charge of the (non) investigation of her sister’s “accident,” not only has nothing been done but Rose has ended up in a psychiatric hospital twice for a few days each. It’s never made explicitly clear but from what I gather, she left her stove on twice to the point the fire department was called (though there’s no mention of smoke damage to her apartment) and she hears her dead sister talking to her in her head and (I’m guessing) sometimes talks out loud in reply. Then she finds something that she’s sure will get the sergeant to see what Rose has been saying all along – Daisy’s death was no accident and not only that, her death mirrors that of another woman six months prior.
Of course nothing works out as Rose hopes but she catches a break when she discovers and unexpectedly connects online with someone who also lost a person to an “accident.” Orin actually believes Rose and Rose believes Orin. Together the two begin to try and find what might have linked Daisy to Orin’s sister-in-law only to realize that they’ve got something much worse on their hands.
Orin and several other characters are written in such a way that Rose is alternatively sure and unsure of what their motives might be. Things happen, people act strangely but there are reasons for all this. Right? This could just be Rose being more paranoid (both mentally and due to what she’s worried is happening) or a coincidence. Yes? Or is someone really after Rose, trying to cut off her investigation and maybe kill her?
I waffled back and forth a bit before settling on my pick for whodunnit. Rose and Co finally realize who the killer probably is which sets up a fast paced finale showdown. Rose does her fair share of “I know I shouldn’t do [whatever]” before she goes ahead and does just that but to her credit, what she does isn’t TSTL level stuff. There are some slightly, okay fairly, unbelievable things that conveniently occur to speed the plot along but I wanted to know what was going to happen and how all the pieces of the puzzle were going to fit together. I was left with a few niggling questions such as how did the killer choose his victims and manage to kill the last person, but most everything else was wrapped up and the feeling I get is that Daisy won’t be “talking” to Rose anymore. The twist at the end? That did catch me by surprise though. B-
~Jayne